Skip to content
Blog
12 minute read
12 May 2023

Closed Captioning: Everything You Need to Know About It

Table of content

This guideline covers everything you need to know about closed captioning. It explains the importance of closed captioning, how it works, and its differentiation from subtitles and open captions. Additionally, it addresses the benefits, legal requirements, and best practices for implementing closed captioning. Whether you’re a content creator or interested in accessibility, this guideline provides valuable insights for understanding and utilizing closed captioning effectively.

Importance of closed captioning in media and communication

Closed captioning plays a crucial role in enabling individuals with hearing loss to fully comprehend and engage with audiovisual content. By providing a textual representation of the dialogue, sound effects, and other audio elements, closed captions allow those with hearing impairments to access and understand the content on an equal footing with individuals without hearing loss. This accessibility ensures that people with hearing disabilities can enjoy movies, TV shows, online videos, and other forms of media without missing out on essential information or dialogue.

Moreover, closed captioning extends the reach of content to a broader audience. It benefits not only individuals with hearing loss but also those in noisy environments or learning a new language. In loud environments where audio may be difficult to hear clearly, closed captions allow viewers to follow along and understand the content without relying solely on sound. Additionally, for individuals learning a new language, closed captions provide valuable support by offering a visual representation of the spoken words, helping them improve their language skills and comprehension.

Beyond accessibility, closed captioning promotes social inclusion and diversity. By breaking down communication barriers, it ensures that individuals with hearing impairments can actively participate in conversations and cultural experiences. Closed captions enable seamless communication and engagement, fostering a more inclusive society where everyone can share the same media and cultural references. Furthermore, by considering the needs of individuals with hearing loss, content creators and broadcasters demonstrate their commitment to diversity, accessibility, and equality.

Legal requirements and regulations for closed captioning

Closed captioning is not just a matter of preference but also a legal requirement in many contexts. Various laws, such as the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) and Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulations in the United States, mandate closed captioning to ensure accessibility for individuals with hearing impairments. These legal requirements apply to different forms of media, including television broadcasts, online videos, and streaming platforms.

Content providers and broadcasters are obligated to comply with these regulations to avoid potential legal consequences. Failure to provide closed captions where required may lead to penalties, fines, or legal disputes. By adhering to the legal requirements, content creators and broadcasters demonstrate their commitment to accessibility, inclusivity, and equal participation in media and communication. Compliance with these regulations is not only a legal obligation but also a moral and ethical responsibility to ensure that everyone has equal access to information, entertainment, and cultural experiences.

How Closed Captioning Works

Overview of the closed captioning process

The process of closed captioning involves several key steps. First, the audio content is transcribed into text form, capturing the dialogue, sound effects, and other relevant audio information. This transcription is then segmented into appropriate captions, dividing the text into manageable chunks that align with the timing of the audio. Finally, the captions are synchronized with the audio, ensuring that the text appears on-screen at the right time, corresponding to the spoken words or sounds. Captions are typically embedded within the video file itself or provided as a separate caption file, such as a WebVTT or SRT file.

Techniques and technologies used in closed captioning

Closed captioning can be achieved through different techniques and technologies. Traditional captioning methods involve human transcriptionists who listen to the audio content and manually create the captions. These professionals carefully transcribe the dialogue and other relevant audio elements, ensuring accuracy and appropriate segmentation of the text. On the other hand, automated captioning systems utilize advanced technologies such as speech recognition and machine learning algorithms. These systems analyze the audio and generate captions automatically. They can be trained to recognize and convert spoken words into text, significantly speeding up the captioning process. Hybrid approaches that combine automated systems with human editing and verification are also common, where automated systems generate initial captions that are then reviewed and edited by human experts to ensure accuracy and quality.

Differentiating closed captioning from subtitles and open captions

Closed captioning, subtitles, and open captions serve distinct purposes in media accessibility. Closed captions are specifically designed for individuals with hearing impairments. Viewers have the option to turn closed captions on or off, making them suitable for those who require the text to understand the audio content. Subtitles, on the other hand, primarily serve as translations for non-native language speakers. They assume that the viewer can hear the audio and provide a textual representation of the dialogue in a different language. Subtitles are typically displayed in the viewer’s language of choice. Open captions, also known as burned-in captions, are permanently displayed on-screen and cannot be turned off. They provide accessibility to all viewers, regardless of their hearing abilities or language preferences.

Understanding the distinctions between closed captioning, subtitles, and open captions is crucial in ensuring the appropriate implementation of accessibility features for different audiences and contexts.

Benefits and Impact of Closed Captioning

Accessibility for individuals with hearing impairments

Closed captioning plays a vital role in providing accessibility for individuals with hearing impairments. It enables people who are deaf or hard of hearing to access and understand audio content, ensuring they have equal opportunities to engage with education, entertainment, news, and other forms of media. By providing accurate captions, closed captioning breaks down barriers and empowers individuals with hearing impairments to participate fully in the digital and media landscape.

Enhanced comprehension and learning for diverse audiences

Closed captions benefit a wide range of individuals beyond those with hearing impairments. Non-native language speakers can significantly benefit from closed captions, as they provide a visual representation of the spoken words, aiding comprehension and language learning. Moreover, individuals with cognitive disabilities may find closed captions helpful in improving information retention and engagement with the content. Additionally, in noisy environments where audio clarity may be compromised, closed captions ensure that viewers can follow along and understand the content without relying solely on sound.

Increased reach and inclusivity for content creators

By implementing closed captions in videos and broadcasts, content creators can expand their potential audience. Closed captions make content accessible to individuals with hearing impairments, non-native language speakers, and those in noisy environments, maximizing the impact and reach of the content. Moreover, providing closed captions demonstrates a commitment to accessibility and inclusivity, which fosters a positive brand image and social responsibility. By embracing closed captioning, content creators showcase their dedication to ensuring equal access and participation for all individuals, contributing to a more inclusive and diverse media landscape.

Closed Captioning Standards and Guidelines

Understanding captioning standards (e.g., CEA-608, CEA-708, WebVTT)

To ensure compliance and consistency in closed captioning, it is essential to familiarize yourself with the different captioning standards and protocols commonly used in various platforms and industries. For example, CEA-608 and CEA-708 are widely used for broadcast television, while WebVTT is commonly used for web-based content. Understanding the specific requirements and capabilities of each standard will help you produce closed captions that are compatible and optimized for the intended platform.

Best practices for caption placement, formatting, and synchronization

Proper caption placement, formatting, and synchronization are crucial for optimal readability and viewer experience. When placing captions on the screen, it is important to follow guidelines to avoid obstructing essential visual elements or important on-screen text. Consider factors such as safe areas and readability in determining the ideal placement of captions. Additionally, ensure that captions are formatted appropriately, including font choice, size, color, and contrast, to maximize readability for different viewers. Synchronizing captions accurately with the corresponding audio is vital to maintain alignment throughout the content, preventing delays or discrepancies between the spoken words and the displayed text.

Quality control measures and accuracy in closed captioning

Maintaining high-quality closed captions requires implementing quality control measures and ensuring accuracy. Establishing quality control processes helps in guaranteeing the accuracy and reliability of closed captions. This may involve having designated reviewers who regularly review and edit captions for grammar, spelling, and punctuation errors. Conducting quality checks throughout the captioning workflow helps to verify that captions are synchronized correctly and aligned with the audio, maintaining a seamless viewing experience. By adhering to quality control measures, content creators can provide viewers with accurate and reliable closed captions that enhance comprehension and accessibility.

Note: It is important to consult specific platform guidelines and accessibility standards relevant to your industry to ensure compliance and to stay up to date with any changes or updates to captioning standards and best practices.

Closed Captioning Implementation

Closed captioning options for various media platforms (TV, streaming platforms, online content)

Implementing closed captioning requires understanding the specific options and processes available for different media platforms. Here’s a more detailed breakdown:

Media platforms
  • TV

    Different TV networks and broadcasters may have specific requirements for closed captioning to comply with regulatory standards. Research and understand the captioning protocols commonly used in TV broadcasts, such as CEA-608 or CEA-708. Ensure that your closed captions meet the technical specifications and formatting guidelines set by the respective networks or broadcasters.

  • Streaming platforms

    Streaming platforms often provide built-in closed captioning features or require caption files to be uploaded. Research the specific captioning options and tools provided by each platform. Familiarize yourself with their guidelines for caption formatting, caption file formats (e.g., WebVTT, SRT), and any specific requirements for timing and synchronization.

  • Online content

    When adding closed captions to online videos, different options are available. Captioning software can be used to create and edit captions before embedding them into your video file. Alternatively, captioning services offer professional captioning solutions, where trained experts generate accurate captions for your videos. Research and choose the option that best suits your needs, considering factors such as accuracy, turnaround time, and pricing.

Choosing the right closed captioning service provider

Selecting the right closed captioning service provider is crucial for ensuring high-quality captions and a smooth implementation process. Consider the following factors:

  1. Evaluation: Evaluate different closed captioning service providers based on factors such as accuracy, turnaround time, pricing, and support. Request sample captions or references to assess their quality.
  2. Experience and expertise: Consider the service provider’s experience in handling various content types, languages, and accessibility standards. Verify that they have the necessary expertise to deliver accurate and compliant closed captions.
  3. Legal compliance and quality assurance: Verify that the service provider complies with legal requirements, such as the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or other regional accessibility standards. Check if they have quality control measures in place to ensure the accuracy and reliability of captions.

Tools and software for creating and embedding closed captions

To streamline the captioning process, explore captioning software and tools that offer useful features. Consider the following:

Captioning software: Look for software that supports automatic transcription, speech recognition, and caption synchronization features. Consider using Amberscript, a reliable captioning software that offers advanced technologies to expedite the captioning process and enhance accuracy. Amberscript’s automatic transcription capabilities utilize cutting-edge speech recognition algorithms to transcribe audio content quickly and efficiently. With its speech recognition technology, Amberscript can accurately convert spoken words into text, reducing the time and effort required for manual transcription. Additionally, Amberscript provides caption synchronization features, ensuring that the captions align seamlessly with the corresponding audio. By utilizing Amberscript or similar captioning software, you can streamline the captioning process, increase productivity, and deliver high-quality closed captions efficiently.

Process of creating subtitles with Amberscript

Embedding closed captions: Learn how to embed closed captions into video files using the appropriate file formats and codecs. Understand the designated captioning interfaces provided by different platforms, such as YouTube’s captioning interface or video player integration options.

Compatibility: Ensure that the captioning tools and software you choose are compatible with the target platform’s requirements. Consider factors such as caption file format support and caption positioning options to ensure seamless integration.

By considering these detailed aspects, you can make informed decisions when implementing closed captioning, select the right service provider, and choose suitable tools or software to streamline the captioning process for your specific needs.

Overview of accessibility laws and regulations (e.g., ADA, FCC)

To ensure compliance with accessibility requirements, it is crucial to familiarize yourself with the accessibility laws and regulations specific to your region. For example, in the United States, the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) sets guidelines for equal access and non-discrimination, including provisions for closed captioning. Additionally, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) regulates closed captioning requirements for television broadcasts and certain online content. Understanding the specific closed captioning requirements and deadlines outlined by these regulatory bodies is essential for compliance.

Compliance requirements for closed captioning

To comply with accessibility laws and regulations, it is necessary to ensure that your content meets the necessary accessibility standards and guidelines. This includes implementing closed captioning in a timely manner and making it easily accessible to users. Consider the technical specifications and formatting guidelines provided by regulatory bodies, as well as industry best practices, to ensure your closed captions meet the required standards. It is also advisable to keep records and documentation that demonstrate your compliance with legal requirements, as they may be requested in case of audits or legal inquiries.

Potential penalties for non-compliance and legal implications

Non-compliance with accessibility regulations can have significant legal consequences. Violations may result in penalties, fines, litigation, and reputational damage. It is important to stay informed about legal developments and updates related to closed captioning requirements to avoid penalties and legal disputes. Regularly review and update your closed captioning practices to align with any changes in regulations or industry standards. By proactively adhering to legal requirements and maintaining compliance, you can mitigate the risk of legal implications and ensure equal access for individuals with hearing impairments.

Challenges and Solutions in Closed Captioning

Captions should accurately convey the intended meaning and accommodate linguistic and cultural nuances. Consider the following:

  1. Consider language nuances and cultural references: When creating captions, take into account language nuances, idiomatic expressions, and cultural references. Ensure that captions effectively capture the intended message, humor, or cultural context of the content.
  2. Adapt captions for regional dialects or accents: Accommodate variations in regional dialects or accents to ensure inclusivity and accurate representation. Consider providing optional dialect-specific captions or including glossaries for better comprehension.
  3. Consult language experts or native speakers: Engage with language experts or native speakers to ensure the accuracy and cultural appropriateness of captions. Their insights and guidance can help ensure that the captions effectively convey the intended meaning and cultural nuances.

Strategies for handling live events and real-time captioning

Live events and real-time captioning require specific strategies and resources to ensure accurate and timely captions. Consider the following:

Understand specific requirements and techniques

Familiarize yourself with the requirements and techniques for providing live captioning, such as stenography or respeaking. These methods involve skilled captioners transcribing speech in real time.

Plan and allocate resources

Adequately plan and allocate resources to ensure accurate and timely captions during live broadcasts or events. This may include hiring experienced captioners, using specialized equipment, or leveraging real-time collaboration tools.

Utilize specialized equipment and tools

Invest in specialized equipment or software designed for live captioning to ensure high-quality captions. Real-time collaboration tools can enable seamless communication between captioners and production teams, facilitating accurate and synchronized captions.

Resources and Tools for Closed Captioning

Online resources for learning more about closed captioning

To enhance your understanding of closed captioning, explore various online resources that provide valuable information and insights. Consider the following:

  1. Explore accessibility organizations: Websites and resources offered by accessibility organizations, such as the W3C Web Accessibility Initiative (WAI), can provide comprehensive guidelines and standards for closed captioning.
  2. Official guidelines and research papers: Access official guidelines and research papers that delve into closed captioning best practices, advancements, and legal requirements. These resources can offer in-depth knowledge and insights into the field.
  3. Captioning-focused blogs and forums: Engage with accessibility-focused blogs, forums, or online communities where professionals and enthusiasts discuss closed captioning techniques, challenges, and innovations. Platforms like Captioning Key provide valuable resources and practical tips for captioning content effectively.

Captioning software and tools for content creators

To streamline the closed captioning process, consider utilizing captioning software and tools. Here are some key points to consider:

  1. Research captioning software: Explore and evaluate captioning software that simplifies the creation, editing, and embedding of closed captions. Look for features such as automatic transcription, caption synchronization, and support for various caption file formats.
  2. Cloud-based solutions: Consider cloud-based captioning solutions that offer accessibility across multiple devices and collaboration features. These tools enable seamless collaboration between team members, making the captioning process more efficient.

Professional organizations and services for closed captioning

Partnering with professional closed captioning services and joining relevant organizations can provide valuable support and resources. Consider the following:

  1. Professional captioning services: Collaborate with reputable closed captioning service providers that specialize in delivering high-quality captions. Look for providers with a proven track record of accuracy, quick turnaround times, and good customer support.
  2. Join professional organizations or associations: Engage with professional organizations or associations that focus on closed captioning and accessibility. These groups can provide resources, networking opportunities, and industry insights to stay updated with the latest developments and best practices in closed captioning.
  3. Seek recommendations: Reach out to peers and industry experts for recommendations on reliable captioning service providers. Their experiences and insights can help you identify trustworthy resources and services.

Closed captioning is a vital component of accessibility and inclusivity in media and communication. By implementing closed captioning effectively, content creators can ensure equal access, reach wider audiences, and comply with legal requirements. By following the guidelines and best practices outlined in this document, you can create a more inclusive and engaging media landscape that caters to diverse viewers.

Frequently asked questions

  • Can I burn the subtitles directly onto my video?

    If you have exported the transcript as a SRT, EBU-STL or VTT file, you can easily burn them onto your video using video-editing software.

  • Can I change the position of the subtitles?

    That needs to be done using a video editor like VLC. Go to Tools > Preferences [CTRL + P]. Under Show settings, select the option that says All to switch to the advanced preferences. Navigate to Input/Codecs > Subtitle codecs > Subtitles. Under Text subtitle decoder set, the Subtitle justification to left, right or center.

  • How do I add subtitles to a YouTube video?

    To add subtitles to your Youtube video, simply add the file you have created using Amberscript to your video in the Youtube Studio. Click on “subtitles”, then “add” and finally “upload file” and select the SRT file.

  • How do I add subtitles to a video on Vimeo?

    To add subtitles to your Vimeo video, simply add the file you have created using Amberscript to your video in the editing window on Vimeo. Click on “distribution”, then “subtitles” and finally click on the + symbol to upload the SRT file.

  • How do I order translated subtitles?

    To order translated subtitles, you can upload your file like you would normally do. You can then select manual subtitling. Once you have selected this, an option will appear where you will be able to select the language the subtitles need to be translated to. If the language that you want is not one of the options you can contact us through our contact form.

  • To which languages can you translate subtitles?

    For our human-made subtitling services we work with a network of language experts in 15 different languages. Find out which here. If the language you want is not on the list, please contact us through our contact form.

  • What subtitle file formats are supported?

    Our software allows you to export the transcript from the video or audio file as an SRT, EBU-STL or VTT file.

Interesting topics